Fitness is one of those industries that can look almost perfect from the outside.

You have recurring membership revenue. Consumers increasingly care about their health. Many concepts build strong communities around their brands. And unlike plenty of businesses, you can actually watch your product change someone's life.

So, naturally, someone who loves working out might look at all of that and think: Why wouldn't I want to own a fitness franchise?

Because loving fitness and running a successful fitness business are two very different things.

That's the conversation I recently had with Chris Peña, President of Franchise Development for Sequel Brands, on Fran Opps Live. Chris has been an entrepreneur since his teens, has owned and developed businesses inside and outside fitness, and helped build BODY20 before becoming part of the team behind Sequel Brands. His experience has given him a front-row seat to both what works in fitness franchising—and what doesn't.

His message for prospective owners is refreshingly straightforward:

“There's no business that's easy. Simple doesn't mean easy.”

That's probably the best place to start.

Fitness attracts prospective owners for reasons other industries often don't. Maybe your spouse loves Pilates. You're passionate about strength training. Your friends are always asking you for workout advice. You've personally experienced a fitness transformation and want to help other people do the same.

Those can all be reasons to explore the industry.

They are terrible reasons to assume you'll succeed in it.

Chris told me fitness businesses frequently get viewed as what he calls a “hobby business”—something that appears relatively easy to operate because the product is fun and familiar.

He sees a common assumption: someone is charismatic, in shape, loves fitness and knows plenty of other people who love fitness, so opening a studio seems like a natural fit.

Chris couldn't disagree more.

“People don't always look at us as a sophisticated business model. They look at it as this kind of hobby business...if I like it and I'm good at it and I look like I'm in shape, I'll be successful. Absolutely the furthest thing from the truth.”

A fitness franchise still has payroll. Rent. Marketing expenses. Customer acquisition costs. Staffing challenges. Sales processes. Retention. Local competition. Management. Cash flow.

The workout might be the product.

The business is still the business.

And prospective owners who fail to separate those two ideas can get themselves into trouble quickly.

This may have been the most valuable part of my conversation with Chris.

Everyone wants to know how much revenue a franchise can generate. That's understandable. But revenue alone can hide an enormous amount of information.

Chris shared an example from his BODY20 experience. During an especially strong period, locations were producing impressive revenue. But when conditions changed, they discovered an underlying problem: franchisees weren't paying enough attention to a key operational metric—how much gross profit was being produced per trainer hour.

The result?

“Our revenues were higher than they'd ever been, but our margins were decreasing.”

Think about that.

Sales are up.

Revenue looks great.

And the actual economics of the business are moving in the wrong direction.

That's why Chris says owners have to understand where the “leaky buckets” are in their businesses. Every model has them. The important question is whether the owner—and the franchisor—knows what to measure so they can find them.

This principle goes far beyond fitness.

When evaluating any franchise, don't just ask, “How much revenue can a location generate?”

Ask what actually drives profitability.

Ask which expenses most dramatically affect margins.

Ask which KPIs successful franchisees monitor every week.

And ask whether the franchisor is merely tracking top-line revenue or actually paying attention to franchisee profitability.

Chris suggested a particularly useful due-diligence question:

“Ask the franchisor: what are the three metrics that matter?”

Then take it one step further.

Ask the franchisees the same question.

If the franchisor tells you three critical metrics but its franchisees have no idea what you're talking about, that tells you something about how effectively the system is being taught and implemented.

This is where prospective buyers can unintentionally sabotage themselves before they even open.

You hear about a franchisee who absolutely crushed it.

Huge opening.

Great revenue.

Strong profitability.

And immediately you start doing the math:

If they did it, I can do it.
​
Maybe.

But their outcome isn't your business plan.

Chris shared an example of a former franchisee who had an exceptional opening and first year. On paper, it was exactly the kind of success story any prospective owner would want to emulate.

What those numbers didn't immediately reveal were all the variables surrounding them. The owner had deep roots in the market.

There were existing relationships. His partner's wife owned another successful business serving a similar clientele. They didn't have debt on the business. There were several circumstances contributing to the result that wouldn't necessarily exist for the next franchisee.

That's why one exceptional franchisee can be both inspiring and dangerous if you turn their performance into your expectation.

Your market is different.

Your debt structure may be different.

Your relationships are different.

Your experience is different.

Your ability to execute will be different.

A good franchise investigation shouldn't be about discovering the biggest number you can find and convincing yourself you'll replicate it.

It should be about understanding why different franchisees produce different results.

There's another question Chris recommends asking that I think more franchise buyers should put on their list:

Does this franchisor measure gross revenue—or bottom-line performance?

Every franchisor has an incentive to track revenue. In most franchise systems, royalties are tied to it.

But Chris argues that a more sophisticated support system should also understand what's happening beneath the top line.

As he explained:

“It matters that your franchisor is paying attention if you're making money or not.”

Imagine the difference between a support call that says, “Great job, revenue increased 10%,” and one that says, “Your labor expense is significantly higher than comparable locations, and it's hurting your margin. Let's figure out why.”

Those are two very different levels of franchise support.

More revenue doesn't automatically fix a poorly managed business.

Sometimes it just makes the poorly managed business bigger.

Another misconception Chris addressed is the type of person who can own a fitness franchise.

Do you need six-pack abs?

No.

Do you need to spend two hours in the gym every morning?

No.

Do you need to be the best athlete in the room?

No.

But there is something you probably can't avoid: people.

Fitness is an extraordinarily community-driven business. A successful local owner may need to build partnerships, attend events, talk about the brand, engage with members and become visible in the community.

Chris described one particularly successful franchisee this way:

“Everywhere he went was BODY20.”

That owner became so associated with the brand locally that, as Chris put it, people in the market knew the franchisee as “Mr. BODY20”—not necessarily the founders themselves.

That doesn't mean you need to become a door-to-door salesperson.

It means you can't expect to hide behind the logo.

Chris put it plainly:

“We're such a community-oriented business that if you're not willing to go to the community, your team isn't either.”

That's a fit question prospective owners need to take seriously.

If the business requires a locally engaged owner and you have absolutely no interest in being locally engaged, don't convince yourself you'll become a different person after signing the franchise agreement.

Find a model that fits who you actually are.

Chris told a great story about his wife when they opened their first BODY20 location.

She had been a fourth-grade teacher and made something very clear: she was not going to sell memberships.

Then the business opened.

Several weeks later, Chris watched her move from desk to desk, talking with prospects and closing memberships. He finally pulled her aside and essentially asked what happened to the woman who refused to sell.

Her response was that she wasn't selling anything. She simply understood what could happen to these people if they didn't address their health problems.

Chris realized that she had discovered what good sales actually is.

“If you believe in the product, it's not a sale. It's a, ‘Hey, I can help you, and I'm not going to let you leave not knowing that I can help you.’”

That distinction is enormous for someone evaluating a fitness franchise.

You shouldn't choose a brand merely because you saw attractive financial numbers.

You need to believe in what the customer is buying.

Because eventually you're going to have to tell someone why it matters.

And that brings us back to passion—but a very different kind of passion than simply loving fitness.

Chris said:

“Where you get passion in your business is when you see that business helping somebody...You don't get it because I thought this was cool. That wears off fast.”

That's the difference between being passionate about a concept and becoming passionate about the impact of the business.

The second one has a much better chance of surviving payroll, staffing problems, slow months and the realities of ownership.

There's a reason fitness franchises attract entrepreneurs.

The recurring revenue can be appealing. The customer impact is real. Community can create tremendous loyalty. And for the right owner, building a business around health and wellness can be deeply fulfilling.

But that's exactly why prospective owners have to be careful not to fall in love with the idea of the business before understanding the business itself.

Chris made a point during our conversation that applies to almost every franchise system:

“There is a top-performing franchisee in every system in the country, and there's a bottom-performing franchisee in every system in the country—and they have the exact same systems.”

That's worth remembering.

A great brand matters.

A great system matters.

A great market matters.

But the operator still matters.

So if you're evaluating a fitness franchise, don't stop at whether the concept is cool, whether consumers love it, or whether the Item 19 contains an exciting number.

Figure out how the business actually works.

Understand what drives the economics.

Determine whether the franchisor knows those drivers and teaches them effectively.

Talk to franchisees.

Understand the customer.

And be candid about whether you're willing to become the local owner that model requires.

Because there's a big difference between a workout people love and a business worth investing your money into.

Your job is to figure out whether you've found both.